But tar sands opponents fighting a powerful international industry are likened to terrorists. Tar sands development comes with an enormous environmental and human cost. The concept of free speech is nonexistent at environment canada. In 2006, the harper government introduced strict procedures around how its scientists are allowed to speak about their research to the media. Climate scientist claims stephen harpers government has. A word of advice for canadas newly unmuzzled scientists. The war on science is a good polemic against our current federal government. Canada to probe alleged muzzling of scientists canadas information commissioner on tuesday launched an investigation into allegations that the. Muzzled scientists and wilful blindness in stephen harpers canada kindle edition by turner, chris. Turner questions how government is making decisions on oil. The canadian government has introduced a new model scientific integrity policy to protect its public sector scientists from political interference, and the countrys research community, including highprofile chemists, applaud the development. The two groups pointed to several instances where federal scientists have been muzzled and the tactics the government has been using to control discussion about everything from.
Ill be writing up posts over the next few days on the more interesting sessions ive been to of those, there are many but i wanted to start with the discussion generated by a panel discussion looking at the worrying trend towards scientists who work for governmentowned organisations being discouraged or even banned from publicly. Harper governments muzzling of federal scientists to be. For government scientists, these would come from communications departments, and thats an area where i think reinvestment is still being made. After muzzling scientists, canadian government now moves on. Scientists feel muzzled by conservative government, union. Canadian scientists offer support to muzzled us counterparts. Six whistleblowers and exgovernment scientists describe how the trump. Jan 01, 20 the war on science documents the attempts of the harper government to claim credit for the successes of preceding governments while trying to destroy the reputations and public images of other politicians and to destroy the ability of citizens obviously regarded as opponents to access, understand, or even investigate the scientific and sociological evidence that would illuminate the deceit. Jan 07, 2014 after muzzling scientists, canadian government now moves on to book burnings. May 24, 2015 government scientists get permission to meet with union at workplace. A government source pointed out that in 2012, environment canada scientists conducted 1,300. However, he also illustrates canadas long tradition of worldleading independent inquiry and governments willing to consider the.
Muzzled scientists and wilful blindness in stephen harpers canada is a solidly researched, wellwritten book that. Most of the stories were amply covered by the press over the past few years, but chris turner puts it together in such a way as to make it hurt all over again. Apr 29, 2017 media access to government scientists working on climate and environmental topics all but vanished, and in several egregious cases individual scientists were directly muzzled, forbidden to speak. They cooked the books and changed every assumption they could to get. Canadian scientists explain exactly how their government.
It is now a fact that global warming is a complete fraud and hoax. Vancouver, british columbia less than a month into the trump presidency, and the forecast for science seems ominous. When canadian scientists were muzzled by their government. Dismissing critics of the government on the grounds that theyre criticizing the government is a bit weak, i fear. Its official the harper government muzzled scientists. Its essential to let them speak candidly to the press again.
We hear from a diverse group of credible scientists who clearly document a troubling initiative quietly implemented by the canadian government. The investigation was launched amid a torrent of reports that federal scientists were being muzzled by the then conservative government of stephen harper see here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here and here. The trump administration is muzzling government scientists. B y sheer chance, i was reading chris turners scathing new book, the war on science. To give the right answer even if its the incorrect answer. Both of the above are the life blood of scientific progress.
Ottawa if stephen harper muzzled federal government scientists, then justin trudeau has failed to lift the muzzle, a federal public sector union says in a memo obtained by postmedia network. Apr 18, 2020 april 18, 2020 april 18, 2020 the trump administration is muzzling government scientists. Half of canadas government scientists still feel muzzled science. Canadian scientists are muzzled by their government. Ottawa a large survey of science professionals in the federal public service has found. They are employees of the united states and they will obey the orders given them, do the specific tasks assigned them and hand over whatever documentselectronic records. Federal scientists muzzled by media policies, report. Generally wellwritten, though somewhat repetitious and focused entirely on scientists who are government employees and governmentsupported programs, such as the experimental lakes area.
Muzzled scientists and wilful blindness in stephen. May 22, 2015 some government scientists feel muzzled posted may 22, 2015 public service unions want the right for their members to speak out on matters pertaining to science and their own research as long as they make it clear that they are speaking in their personal capacity and not on behalf of the government of canada. Drawing on interviews with scientists whose work has been halted by budget cuts and their colleagues in an ngo nongovernmental organization community increasingly treated as an enemy of the state, journalist chris turner paints a vivid portrait of a government that he claims has abandoned environmental stewardship and severed a national commitment to the objective truths of basic science. Maurice, i think a rather large number of scientists employed in the civil service are harper bashers, because of the kind of incident described in the ohara article. All of the government scientists who complain about being muzzled are the ones who are trying to promote their own personal theories which are not supported by the bulk of the evidence. This is an excerpt from second opinion, a weekly roundup of eclectic and undertheradar health and medical science news emailed to. Techdirt has been following for a while the canadian governments unabashed attempts to muzzle scientists and librarians who work for the state, as it tries to deny them the right to express their. The governments lobbying ban will have a chilling impact on. Its time for action on canadas muzzled scientists the tyee. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the war on science.
Canadian scientists welcome new research integrity policy. More than half of federal government scientists still feel. Mar 14, 2020 trump is breaking every rule in the cdcs 450page playbook for health crisis the communication chaos on coronavirus is eroding the most powerful weapon we have. May 22, 2015 scientists working for the federal government want the right to speak out about their research. May 30, 20 its no secret the harper government has a problem with science. Muzzled scientists and wilful blindness in stephen harpers canada. Trump is breaking every rule in the cdcs 450page playbook for health crisis the communication chaos on coronavirus is eroding the most powerful weapon we have. Ottawa if stephen harper muzzled federal government scientists.
Evolutionary narrative in darwin, george eliot and nineteenthcentury fiction. Government scientists get permission to meet with union at. Robert oppenheimer on the manhattan project, or for another role that requires scientific training and methods. After muzzling scientists, canadian government now moves. May 17, 20 the government has muzzled government scientists, insulted nasa climate experts, and dismissed environmental protesters as dangerous radicals. After muzzling scientists, canadian government now moves on to book burnings. Apr 18, 2020 the trump administration is muzzling government scientists. Scientists attack their muzzling by government this article is more than 4 years old statefunded scientists could be prevented from lobbying for change in. Federal scientists eager to share their research now that muzzles are off. Over the next few years, government scientists would experience a tightening of. Mind you, data quietly tabled in the house of commons earlier this summer suggests. The federal government says it is not muzzling its scientists, but others inside and outside canadas scientific community are concerned with what they see as an alarming trend to limit the free.
Government scientists occupy a special place in our democracy. Scientists going to professional conferences have media minders to be sure nothing gets in the press that would contradict the government s current policies. As for the complaints of these so called government climate scientists. But he did not address the allegations that scientists are being muzzled. Brussels book fair celebrates morocco as guest of honor. Vancouveras thousands of researchers gather in vancouver for an international conference, focus has turned to the canadian government. Some government scientists feel muzzled new start nova scotia. Climate scientist claims stephen harpers government has muzzled experts.
Mar 14, 2016 the governments lobbying ban will have a chilling impact on scientists david nutt. Scientists discover new flying reptile fossils in moroccan sahara. Scientists attack their muzzling by government science. Federal scientists eager to share their research now that. Initial reports said some books were literally burned which the. Canadas government wont let its own climate scientists speak to the press our northern neighbors are taking a page from george w.
A recent flurry of articles from sun media have appeared in the news over the past few days to question a whether muzzling has changed under the new liberal government, b whether it was just made up in the first place by disgruntled scientists, or c it was all hype, or worse yet that the scientists had some alternative agenda in mind. These cases were uncovered by investigative reporters. Social media accounts and websites have been censored, and at least one agency was asked to identify personnel who worked on. The same problem exists with publication in professional journals if government scientists want to keep their jobs. A detailed examination of sinister, shortsighted policy and practice by the harper government, this book lays bare the messaging and spin. Jul 30, 2017 the job of a government climate scientist is to steal as many tax payer dollars as they can. In fact, canadas scientists are so frustrated with this governments recent overhaul of scientific communications policies and cuts to research programs they took to the streets, marching on parliament hill last summer to decry the death of evidence. The war on science documents the attempts of the harper government to claim credit for the successes of preceding governments while trying to destroy the reputations and public images of other politicians and to destroy the ability of citizens obviously regarded as opponents to access, understand, or even investigate the scientific and sociological evidence that would illuminate the. Legault made a series of recommendations to the trudeau government, which took office in 2015, to ensure that government science is available to the public and that scientists are not afraid to speak freely to the media. Muzzled scientists and wilful blindness in stephen harpers canada turner, chris on. It shows how forced silence has driven away some of the canadian governments best scientists. Comprehensive account of the devastating effect of canadian government science policy on the national scientific community. The harper government has trashed and destroyed environmental. It occurred to me that the unerring surgical excision of.
Canadas government wont let its own climate scientists. A new book by chris turner lays bare stephen harpers stifling war. And moore told me of one climate researcher from overseas, currently. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Federal scientists say theyre being muzzled the star. Canadian scientists who were muzzled for nearly a decade by the countrys previous conservative government have been making contact with their counterparts in the us to offer their. Muzzled scientists and wilful blindness in stephen harpers canada, at the same time as gillian beers 30yearold scholarly tome, darwins plots. Chris turner chris turner argues that stephen harpers attack on basic science, science communication, environmental regulations, and the environmental ngo community is the most vicious assault ever waged by a. Some government climate scientists have been muzzled from speaking at conferences under the trump administration, after all. In some countries other terms such technical officers is also used for scientists. Ottawa if stephen harper muzzled federal government scientists, then justin trudeau has failed to lift the muzzle, a federal public sector union says. The discussion of muzzled science includes a lot of discussions of government policy and the role of government scientists in pointing out the flaws with it, although that may not be the primary. The book explains why scientists have concluded that if there isnt a 60percent reduction in these gases by 2050.
Drawing on interviews with scientists whose work has been halted by budget cuts and their colleagues in an ngo community increasingly treated as an enemy of the state, the war on science paints a vivid and damning portrait of a government that has abandoned environmental stewardship and severed a nation. Sep 15, 2015 its time for action on canadas muzzled scientists. Turners book is a harsh indictment of ultra conservative prime minister stephen harpers administration and the antiscience movement in general. Government scientists engaged in a public relation campaign about muzzling. They object to being muzzled by the requirement, currently in place, that they seek permission. Arctic, the trump administration is accused of muzzling climate science. It looks like stephen harpers conservative government has ripped another page out of george w. Protesters, one dressed as a scientist right, posed during a 20 demonstration against the muzzling of canadian government employees in. Trump is breaking every rule in the cdcs 450page playbook. All were offlimits during the harper administration.
Jan 30, 2017 canadian scientists explain exactly how their government silenced science it wasnt just climate research. Meanwhile, some federal scientists say they still feel muzzled by the current government. Regardless, the evidence seems to suggest that when the. The goal was to get the public to support public scientists and to stop governments from laying them off. Justin trudeaus centerleft government swept in on a platform that put scientists right to speak and the promise of evidence. Artist finds inspiration in canadian governments attempt to. Independent government scientists are being muzzled by their business bosses as we have recently seen with the national weather service and hurricane dorians path. Federal scientists muzzled by tories investigated by. It cites the impact of savage budget cuts on morale and in practical terms. Information commissioner strangely silent on muzzled. A government scientist is a scientist employed by a countrys government, either in a researchdriven job for example j. Aug 08, 2016 ottawa if stephen harper muzzled federal government scientists, then justin trudeau has failed to lift the muzzle, a federal public sector union says in a memo obtained by postmedia network. Harper government muzzling environment canada scientists desmog. Theinvestor there was the official story and then there was everything else, the former editor of the nations health, an.
1085 1179 47 88 1108 660 381 114 849 129 17 1154 1191 1445 845 1521 1166 1323 1512 709 800 660 939 336 853 836 111 522 1292 860 384